The concept of guild wars is the same as zone 4 game.

[SeSephiroth]

The concept of a guild war is a 1 vs 1 guild battle. Whoever destroys the opponent's damage pole first wins.

Friends, what do you think about this?

 

[devious]

Sounds more like a guild tournament than a wars.

Not exactly sure what you are asking, but if you just looking for opinions, here is mine.

Seems like an okey content to have in a game, if you can automate it all.
And for something like this, you need to ensure balanced META (most efficient tactic available).
Otherwise you will end up with crowding, or just stack of OP classes.

Win condition of destroying damage pole, seems very unimaginative of better ways to let guilds battle, as damage is the only key factor, not much tactics involved

 

[SeSephiroth]

Sounds more like a guild tournament than a wars.

Not exactly sure what you are asking, but if you just looking for opinions, here is mine.

Seems like an okey content to have in a game, if you can automate it all.
And for something like this, you need to ensure balanced META (most efficient tactic available).
Otherwise you will end up with crowding, or just stack of OP classes.

Win condition of destroying damage pole, seems very unimaginative of better ways to let guilds battle, as damage is the only key factor, not much tactics involved

This topic is only asking for opinions. Thank you for your answer.

I don't really like the current guild war.

in my country There were alliances formed in the war.

So I want to fix this problem. By making it a pairing.

 

[devious]

This topic is only asking for opinions. Thank you for your answer.

I don't really like the current guild war.

in my country There were alliances formed in the war.

So I want to fix this problem. By making it a pairing.

Alliance forming is part of the social side of MMoRPG's.
What if instead trying to discourage it, make a game content/environment around it.
Thats the way I like to look at such issues, or opportunities should I say

PS. im not sure how guildwar currently works in your source, but in universe, since its 1v1 with declaration you can't even have allies, you can't attack enemy members if its not your guild war.